1991

Played 17: Won 7, Lost 5, Drawn 2, Abandoned 3, Cancelled 1.

Sunday May 5 v Keble College - Cancelled

Sunday May 12 v Old Whitgiftians at Croydon - Lost by 131 runs
Old Whitgiftians 273-8 (M Phelps 130, A D Vokes 50); Sherborne Pilgrims 142 (J M P C Turner 63; R P James 4-27)

1990

Played 18: Won 10, Lost 3, Drawn 4, Abandoned 1, Cancelled 1.

Sunday May 6 v Keble College at Oxford - Won by 183 runs
Sherborne Pilgrims 257-5 dec (D W Thorne 133, R A Matthews 51; M G Evans 4-62); Keble College 74

1989

Played 14: Won 5, Lost 4, Drawn 5, Cancelled 1.

Sunday May 7 v Keble College at Oxford - Won by 115 runs
Sherborne Pilgrims 235-6 dec (J M P C Turner 72); Keble College 120 (S M Chaudhury 52*; P J Hodges 5-25, J E Gay 4-44)

1988

Played 14: Won 5, Lost 2, Drawn 4, Abandoned 3.

Sunday May 1 v Keble College at Oxford - Abandoned

Sunday May 15 v Dorset XI at Sherborne - Drawn
Dorset XI 186-9 dec (G S Calway 55; P M S Slade 4-27); Sherborne Pilgrims 89-8 (J R Hall 4-28)

1987

Played 15: Won 5, Lost 5, Drawn 5.

Sunday May 3 v Keble College at Oxford - Won by 87 runs
Sherborne Pilgrims 212-5 dec (J M Wingfield Digby 59); Keble College 125 (A J Berens 68; W J Rydon 5-22)

1986

Played 15: Won 3, Lost 7, Drawn 5.

Saturday May 3 v Royal Agricultural College at Cirencester - Won by 40 runs
Sherborne Pilgrims 183 (E P J F Lyons 52; C A Lloyd 4-23); Royal Agricultural College 143 (Lyons 5-38)

1985

Played 15: Won 3, Lost 3, Drawn 5, Abandoned 4.

Saturday May 4 v Royal Agricultural College at Cirencester - Won by 4 wickets
Royal Agricultural College 125 (R C A Garrett 5-41); Sherborne Pilgrims 126-6 (M M C F Jones 71)

1984

Played 13: Won 3, Lost 5, Drawn 4, Abandoned 1, Cancelled 1.

Saturday May 7 v Royal Agricultural College at Cirencester - Lost by 7 wickets
Sherborne Pilgrims 180; Royal Agricultural College 183-3 (G Barker 104*)

1982

Played 14: Won 4, Lost 7, Drawn 3.

Saturday May 1 v Royal Agricultural College at Cirencester - Lost by 22 runs
Royal Agricultural College 229-5 dec (R C H Seager 58, M R Mitcham 53); Sherborne Pilgrims 207 (A D Brearley 108; W P Willis 4-78)

1981

Played 15: Won 5, Lost 3, Drawn 5, Abandoned 2.

Saturday May 2 v Royal Agricultural College at Cirencester - Drawn
Royal Agricultural College 173-8 dec (N T Gadsby 72, J Carwood 51; N A C Dudley 4-30); Sherborne Pilgrims 98-8